Best Restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL Select A Different City In FloridaSelect A Cuisine To Narrow Your SearchView AllAmericanCoffee7 Mile Cafe & Kava Bar$Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe$Big Pine Rooster$$Coco’s Kitchen$Coconuts Bar & Drive Thru Liquor Store$Good Food Conspiracy$Island Pizza Company$$No Name Pub$$Paradise BSB$$Trianos Taco Company$$